Treat the cause first, then manage symptoms medically, and reserve surgery for symptomatic patients with an inactive underlying condition.
Treat the underlying cause
- Granulomatosis with polyangiitis: induction with corticosteroid plus rituximab or cyclophosphamide, then maintenance, under rheumatology supervision. Surgical repair must be deferred until sustained remission, generally at least 12 months, since operating on active disease fails and can accelerate destruction.
- Sarcoidosis: corticosteroid and steroid sparing agents.
- Infection: specific antimicrobial therapy.
- Cocaine: complete cessation with substance misuse support, and documented abstinence for at least 12 months before any repair is considered. Repairing a perforation in a patient who continues to use will fail.
- Stop septal directed nasal sprays and retrain technique, aiming laterally away from the septum.
- Remove occupational exposure.
- Malignancy: oncological management.
Medical management of symptoms, which is sufficient for many patients
- Nasal saline irrigation with large volume isotonic solution two or three times daily, which is the single most effective measure for crusting.
- Emollients applied to the perforation edges: petroleum jelly, glucose in glycerine 25 percent, sesame or almond oil, or a proprietary nasal gel, applied two or three times daily.
- Humidification of the bedroom air.
- Antibiotic ointment such as mupirocin 2 percent for secondary infection and for staphylococcal colonisation of the crusts.
- Avoid digital trauma, which perpetuates enlargement.
- Stop smoking.
- Manage epistaxis conservatively. Avoid bilateral cautery at the same point, which caused the perforation in many patients and will enlarge it.
Septal button prosthesis
- A silastic obturator with flanges on both sides, sized to the perforation, inserted under local or general anaesthesia.
- Indicated for symptomatic perforations in patients unsuitable for or unwilling to undergo surgery, for very large perforations, for those with active underlying disease, and as a trial to predict the benefit of surgical closure.
- Custom made buttons from a mould fit better and are tolerated longer than stock sizes.
- It abolishes whistling and reduces crusting and bleeding in the majority.
- Complications: irritation, crusting at the flange edges, extrusion, and enlargement of the perforation from pressure necrosis. Requires regular cleaning and periodic review.
Surgical repair
Indications: symptomatic perforation with crusting, bleeding or whistling that persists despite medical therapy, in a patient with an inactive underlying cause, who does not use cocaine, and who does not smoke.
Principles:
- Three layer closure is the aim: mucosal flaps on both sides plus an interposition graft between them.
- The interposition graft provides a scaffold for mucosal regrowth and prevents re perforation. Options are temporalis fascia, which is the most commonly used, mastoid periosteum, perichondrium, conchal cartilage, and acellular dermal matrix.
- Closure of both mucosal layers is ideal, but closure of one side plus an interposition graft frequently succeeds, since the other side epithelialises over the graft.
Approaches:
- Open septorhinoplasty approach with a columellar incision, which gives the best exposure for large perforations and allows simultaneous correction of external deformity. This is the preferred approach for perforations above 2 cm.
- Endonasal or endoscopic approach for smaller perforations, with less morbidity but more restricted access.
- Bilateral mucosal advancement and rotation flaps, releasing the mucosa along the nasal floor and at the junction with the lateral wall to allow tension free advancement.
- Inferior turbinate flaps, pedicled anteriorly or posteriorly, which bring in well vascularised tissue for large defects.
- Anterior ethmoidal artery based flaps and nasal floor flaps.
- Nasoseptal flap based on the posterior septal branch of the sphenopalatine artery, for posterior defects.
- Facial artery musculomucosal flap and free tissue transfer for very large or previously failed repairs.
Outcomes:
- Complete closure rates of 80 to 95 percent for perforations under 2 cm with an experienced surgeon, falling substantially for larger perforations and for revision cases.
- Even where complete closure fails, symptoms frequently improve if the perforation is reduced in size.
- Perforations larger than 3 cm, those in active vasculitis, those in continuing cocaine users, and those in smokers have high failure rates, and a button may be a more honest recommendation.
Postoperative care
- Silastic splints for 2 to 4 weeks to protect the repair and prevent adhesions.
- Saline irrigation and emollients from the first week.
- Avoid nose blowing, straining and nasal instrumentation for 4 to 6 weeks.
- Endoscopic review at 2 weeks, 6 weeks and 3 months.
- Absolute smoking cessation, since smoking is strongly associated with failure.
Follow up in unrepaired perforations
Review periodically to detect enlargement, dorsal collapse and any change in appearance suggesting an evolving underlying disease, and repeat biopsy where the perforation enlarges without explanation.