Symptomatic recurrence generally warrants repair.
After a previous anterior repair, such as Lichtenstein:
Use a posterior preperitoneal repair, preferably TEP or TAPP where expertise is available.
This avoids scarred anterior tissue planes and reduces unnecessary dissection around inguinal nerves and cord structures.
After a previous posterior repair, such as TEP or TAPP:
Use an anterior open repair, usually Lichtenstein.
After both anterior and posterior approaches have failed, management becomes substantially more complex and should be performed by a surgeon with specific expertise in recurrent groin hernia surgery.
At operation, identify the actual cause of failure rather than simply placing additional mesh over an undefined bulge.
Inspect the femoral space, indirect ring and medial direct space.
Avoid unnecessary removal of previous mesh unless it is infected, displaced or directly responsible for significant symptoms. Mesh removal substantially increases the risk of nerve injury, vascular injury, testicular complications and chronic pain.
Recurrent hernia surgery carries greater risk of chronic groin pain, cord injury and another recurrence than primary repair.